A lot of herding dogs in Europe do not live on farms. They live in flats in Berlin, Vienna, Amsterdam and Milan, with a lift, a small balcony and a park ten minutes away. The question we get from those owners is a fair one: a 75 cm ball is a big thing to own when you do not have a garden. Does it still work? It does, with a few adjustments, and this article is about those.
The problem with the flat is not the flat
A herding breed in a small apartment is not short of space in the way people assume. A Border Collie does not need a field to lie down in. What she is short of is an outlet for the stalk-chase-drive wiring that a walk around the block does nothing for. Without one, the usual list follows: barking at the window, nipping at ankles in the hallway, the sofa cushion in pieces. None of that is bad behaviour. It is a working dog with no work, and the fix is not more square metres but a job that fits into the square metres you have. Our article on how to give your dog a job covers the general principle; this one is about doing it from a third-floor flat.
Where to actually play
Not in the flat. We would rather say this plainly than sell you something that bounces off your walls. A herding ball in a hallway becomes a pinball game, hard floors give the dog no grip, and the furniture loses. A very large living room with the furniture pushed back can work for slow, gentle pushing with a small dog, but it is the exception.
What works is the same thing that works everywhere: a patch of grass. For a city dog that means:
- A quiet corner of the park, early morning or late evening, away from the football pitch and the dog-walking crowd. Ten by ten metres of grass is plenty for a fifteen-minute session.
- An empty tennis court or fenced sports pitch, which many cities leave open off-peak. The fence does the work of a garden.
- A fenced dog run, when it is empty. With other dogs present the ball becomes a contest, so pick your time.
- A friend's garden, once a week, for the long session.
Start in whichever of these has the most room and the fewest distractions, roll the ball gently away, nudge it yourself to show her, and praise the first push. The introduction guide has the full sequence.
Getting it there
The ball is big but it is not heavy. For the short walk to the park, carry it inflated the way you would carry a football, or in the drawstring bag that comes with the ballistic cover. For a longer trip, the inner ball lets some air out and the whole thing fits in a bag; a hand pump brings it back in a couple of minutes. In the flat it lives in a cupboard or under a bed between sessions. That is not a compromise. Putting the ball away after play is what keeps it interesting, and a ball that is always out stops being a job and starts being furniture.
The session itself
Ten to fifteen minutes, once or twice a day. Herding is intense work and a city dog with one session a day will go at it hard, so end while she is still engaged and keen rather than running her flat. Keep an eye on the ball when the park is busy: the game is a chase, and a dog in full drive will follow the ball across a path. If she will not disengage when you pick the ball up, the session was too long.
Size matters as much in a park as anywhere. The ball has to be too big to pick up, or the first session ends with her carrying it under the bench. Use the size guide; for a Corgi that is the 45 cm, for a Border Collie usually the 55 cm, for an Aussie the 75 cm, and for a Shepherd or Malinois the 95 cm, which is a big object to walk through a lobby with and still the right one.
The hours you are not there
The ball does not solve the working day. It is a supervised game, not a toy to leave behind, and a dog alone in a flat with a herding ball for eight hours is a dog with a new fixation. For the alone hours the ordinary list applies: a proper session before you leave, so she goes into the day already worked; a puzzle feeder or a frozen food toy; a few treats hidden around the flat; toys rotated through the week rather than all out at once. Build the alone time up gradually if she finds it hard, and if the distress is specific to being left, that is a separate problem for a behaviourist, not an enrichment gap.
What it adds up to
A herding breed in a city needs about twenty minutes a day of the thing she was bred for, and the ball delivers that on any patch of grass you can get to. The flat is where she rests. The park corner is where she works. Keep the two separate, keep the sessions short, put the ball away afterwards, and the question stops being whether a big ball fits in a small flat and starts being why the dog is so calm in the evenings. Our piece on keeping a Border Collie busy has the rest of the city toolkit, and all four sizes are in the shop.